Damon's All American Pizza Pie

Great little pizza shop!

It's a basic, hometown pizza place.

Good pizza, subs and more. Although a bit pricey .

Excellent

We ordered food for dine in.The food was pretty good but the cost was way too high.We had to eat our food with our coats on because the dining room was so COLD!!!.Would probably not come back.

Love this place! Their Stromboli's are amazing... And so is everything else :)

Best pizza around!

Great pizza and sandwich

Got 2 salads that were small, and 2 gyros, also small, and my bill was over $30. That's expensive on its own, but they also forgot the salad dressing and the gyros I had at a festival were better than what I got from here.

They have awesome ham subs and loaded fries and wings

Good food but eating in is not kid friendly. Staff was not sure what to do with dine in guests.

Incredibly expensive and a little slow, but always delicious.

Not too bad. Not a real big fan of sweet sauce pizza, but this one is actually pretty good.

Good pizza family atmosphere

Food was good but the dining room is filthy. And no air

The food was delicious and the service was amazing. I will definitely be back

This is the place you go when you have "extra" money especially if you have a family to feed! 2 pizzas are over $30. The food is great and we love going there but if your on a budget this might break the bank. They used to have a $7 carryout pepperoni pizza special would be great if they brought that back! The subs and gyros and frys don't even get me started. So good!!!!

Awesome food! We were traveling from LA to CT and got stuck in Newcomerstown due to snow. First off, I’m from Connecticut and I KNOW pizza. Pizza and I have a long and loving history and I’m always on the hunt for the best pie. Damon’s does NOT disappoint! Wood fired pizza is 2nd only to coal fired pizza and Damon’s pie had just the right amount of crunch, tasty crust, sauce with just a touch of sweetness and very generous toppings. We also ordered Greek salads which came with a house made Greek dressing (quite tasty) with a TON of feta, kalamata olives and banana peppers. Delivery to our motel was quick and pizza was piping hot on arrival. Highly, highly recommend!

This was my first time eating at Damon's. My wife is from Newcomerstown and she's talked about their pizza for years. We finally went after a trick-or-treat event and got two pizzas. The 5th Inning pizza was really good. Too bad I had to share, haha.

Great pizza and excellent customer service

I am new to the area so we try there food and it's good we order multiple times until last time we get are food and the fries aren't even cooked the put them in the styrofoam container hot so it meals and dis form it and so much Grease all over them then The Stromboli didn't have the marinara sauce so I call in and talk to the manger on duty and he says no problem I'll put a credit in the Computer for next time And it will be fine I just called back in and I get told since we didn't send feedback they can help us with anything Witch is ok but the manger on duty did not tell us to so we wasted our money and will never eat there again

clean, fast service and good food.

The best Calzones and stromboli around only draw back no silverware i for one need to cut my food to eat but if you ask the friendly staff they will allow you to use one from the kitchen

New to the area and definitely found our pizza place! Amazing!!

Great place Jodie is awesome... food is great keep doing what you do

Great food worth the money

This small town pizza place beats ANY place I had pizza before!! Italian food on a thick, delicious, golden baked crust. Try it!!

The spaghetti noodles were hard in the meatballs were cold

Great services, laid back atmosphere.

The people here are completely rude and not very intelligent. I ordered a pizza asking for the Spicy Breaded Chicken topping, and the guy just hung up on me like I was pranking him. I called back, and after repeating my order umpteen times for only two items, I never got an apology or anything. I highly recommend just going to Domino's, they're more friendly and have better attitudes.

Great food, faster than I expected, definitely worth checking out

First time I've been here an very well done cooked pizza an wedges

They were recommended by a gentleman at the truck stop that I was at. I ordered a 12 inch pizza with just about everything on it. I forget what they called it. They delivered it in less than 30 minutes, it was hot and it tasted awesome. It feed 3 adults and I thought it was a reasonable price for what it was. $16.99 plus tip. Thank you.

Never dine in. Never

This is probably my favorite pizza place outside of Jersey. Out of all the pizza I've had, their sauce is sweet instead of being mostly tangy/acidic. Prompt, courteous service and a broad variety of menu items. This is a Newcomerstown icon and worth a visit!

I love this place friendly service,and I haven't found anything here that isn't delicious.

Wonderful pizza and subs. Sauce here is sweet

Fabulous

A little bit expensive but their food is delicious. One of my favorite pizza places, and it tastes WAY better than the cardboard at Terry's.

The sauce amazing

Pizza was ready in 30 minutes after being told 25 then the sauce was bad I had to wait another 30 minutes for the pizza to be remade

Loved the Homerun pizza! A little dated and worn inside when you pick up, but the pizza was amazing! Great job Damon!

Amazing!!!:-). Thanks again

Delicious! We ordered while we were camping at Rocky Fork... totally worth driving into town!!

Love it

Super pizza and pasta. Definitely recommend. Amazing variety of choices on the menu. Prices are reasonable.

Best pizza money can buy